The Tequila Industry: Are Additives a Savior or a Hidden Risk?
Share
As tequila continues to soar in popularity worldwide, we’ve observed a growing phenomenon that’s increasingly coming into focus: the controversy surrounding the use of additives is quietly reshaping the industry. Recently, Mike Dolan, co-founder of the renowned brand Mijenta Tequila, publicly called for the tequila industry to confront and disclose the reality of additive use. This statement not only sparks curiosity but also prompts us to reexamine the secrets hidden in the glass of tequila we hold. In this article, we’ll dive into the truth about tequila additives, exploring their pros and cons, necessity, and their impact on the industry and the cocktail market.
The Origins of the Tequila Additive Controversy
Through our observations, we’ve noted that in August 2024, the Tequila Regulatory Council (CRT) of Mexico issued a ban prohibiting brands from using the term “additive-free” on labels, citing potential consumer confusion and violations of official standards (NOM). This policy directly affects brands like Mijenta Tequila, which emphasize pure flavors, forcing them to rethink how they communicate with consumers. However, the core issue lies deeper: what role do additives play in tequila production?
Further investigation reveals that the use of additives is far from new. According to CRT regulations, 100% agave tequila may contain up to 1% additives—such as glycerin, syrup, caramel coloring, and oak extract—without requiring disclosure. This means many tequilas on the market may already quietly include these “flavor enhancers” without consumers ever knowing.
Why Does Tequila Use Additives? A Pros and Cons Breakdown
Additives aren’t a mandatory part of tequila production; rather, they’re a choice driven by commercial and technical considerations. Here’s our breakdown of their advantages and disadvantages to give you a full picture:
Advantages of Additives
-
Stable Flavor and Consistency – Tequila’s raw material, Blue Weber Agave, is influenced by natural factors, leading to potential flavor variations between batches. Additives like glycerin or syrup can smooth out the taste, adding sweetness and ensuring a consistent experience for consumers with every sip.
-
Broader Market Appeal – For those unaccustomed to tequila’s bold, herbaceous bite, additives (like vanilla or fruit extracts) can soften the profile and make it more approachable, expanding its reach to a wider audience.
-
Cost Reduction and Aging Simulation – Caramel coloring or oak extract can give unaged tequila a darker hue and woody aroma, mimicking the effects of years in a barrel without the time and expense.
-
Compensation for Mass Production – In large-scale production, some distilleries use diffusers to extract juice quickly, which may strip away flavors achieved through traditional slow-cooking methods. Additives can artificially restore what’s lost.
Disadvantages of Additives
-
Masking Natural Flavors – For enthusiasts seeking an authentic tequila experience, additives can obscure the unique grassy and terroir-driven notes of the agave, diluting the spirit’s true character.
-
Transparency Concerns – Since additive use doesn’t require labeling, consumers are left in the dark about whether their tequila is “pure,” eroding trust in brands.
-
Uneven Quality – Over-reliance on additives may lead some producers to skimp on raw material quality or craftsmanship, flooding the market with low-cost, artificially flavored products.
-
Health Questions – While legal additives are deemed safe, the long-term intake of artificial ingredients might still unease some health-conscious consumers.
Are Additives Necessary?
Technically, additives aren’t essential for tequila production. Traditional artisanal brands like Siete Leguas or Tequila Ocho demonstrate that mature agave, slow fermentation, and skilled craftsmanship can produce exceptional flavors without assistance. Yet, for commercial brands, additives offer a shortcut to scale production and compete in the market. Our findings suggest that around 70%-85% of tequilas on the market contain undisclosed additives, highlighting their widespread use.
For consumers, accepting additives is a matter of preference: do you value a consistent, approachable taste, or the raw, natural essence of agave? For producers, it’s a balance between cost and quality.
Current Challenges in the Tequila Industry
The case of Mijenta Tequila is just the tip of the iceberg, as we’ve observed. The CRT’s ban on “additive-free” labeling puts smaller brands at a disadvantage, stripping them of a key marketing edge, while larger brands face scrutiny for their habit of concealing additives. Mike Dolan’s call to action suggests this isn’t just a regulatory issue—it’s a cultural one. A lack of transparency is steadily undermining consumer confidence.
Moreover, the tequila market’s rapid growth has led to a supply challenge. Blue Weber Agave takes 6-10 years to mature, but surging demand has pushed some producers to harvest immature plants, resulting in weaker flavors that often rely on additives to compensate. This intensifies the tension between “natural” and “commercial” tequila.
How Additives Impact the Cocktail Scene
Tequila isn’t just a sipping spirit—it’s a star in the bar world. From classics like the Margarita, Tequila Sunrise, and Paloma to its popularity as a straight shot, tequila’s versatility is undeniable. But do additives affect the cocktail market and consumer tastes?
For bartenders, additives can simplify mixing. A sweeter, smoother tequila blends effortlessly with other ingredients, reducing the need for adjustments. However, if additives overshadow tequila’s natural profile, cocktails might lose their depth, diluting the soul of these classic recipes. For shot enthusiasts, artificial flavors could soften the raw kick that defines the experience, making it feel “less real.”
From a market perspective, if consumers grow wary of additives, bars might need to stock more “additive-free” options to cater to purists. This could steer cocktail trends toward greater transparency and natural ingredients.
Conclusion: What’s the Taste in Your Tequila?
Our observations reveal a key truth behind Mijenta Tequila’s plea: additives aren’t the enemy of tequila, but hiding them might be. For consumers, understanding their pros and cons empowers better choices—do you prefer a polished, additive-enhanced sip or the unfiltered essence of artisanal craft? For the industry and cocktail market, transparency could be the path forward.
